iPhonefreak width="190"

We have been seeing a fair amount of denied or removed apps as of late, and most developers seem to be upset, rightfully so, but until now I have not seen anyone take such a unique plan of action and instead of just accepting the denial, it is being distributed using Apple’s own AdHoc method.

The latest denied app is Podcaster, which according to Apple was denied entry into the App Store because it “duplicates the functionality of the Podcast section of iTunes.” For those who are unfamiliar with this app, Podcaster will allow you to find and stream podcasts over either a cell connection or an available wireless network, you can also choose to download the podcasts directly to your iPhone. Although there is some similar functionality, it certainly does not seem to be the same to me, but maybe Apple thinks different (yes, the bad joke was intended).

The developer was also quick to point out some other apps that offer duplicate features, one example was dealing with weather. I for one replaced my standard Weather app with the more useful WeatherBug. Possibly we should have them removed and banned as well, of course I say that with some sarcasm, but it seems Apple has made a bad call on this one.

Anyway, like I previously mentioned, Podcaster is instead being distributed using the AdHoc method, which means that you can still get the app and that your iPhone will not need to be jailbroken in order to use it. Thankfully this method allows for apps to be offered to other users, so its still able to be found and will not just be lost forever.

I am not 100% familiar with the AdHoc rules, but that seems to be where it gets into technicalities as the developer is not actually selling his app. Instead he is giving it away to users who donate $9.99 or more. Of course in an effort to cover all basis, he is also quick to point out that the “program should work for a minimum of one year but since Apple can turn it off remotely, the 1 year installation is not guaranteed.”

To me, this is just another argument that jailbreaking is still valid. Not only could this app been included in either Installer or Cydia, but with BossPrefs (another jailbroken app) installed you have the option to disable the kill switch, which means no worries about Apple deciding you should not have something installed for your personal use.

Personally I feel this denial is silly, while I am still awaiting delivery on my Podcaster app and have not yet used it, I am pretty comfortable in saying that it will not force me to stop using iTunes for my main podcatching needs. If nothing else it seems that Apple needs to better define their application guidelines.

[Podcaster via uneasySILENCE]